Samuel Rutherford, a prominent Reformed theologian and author of the seminal work Lex, Rex (The Law and the King), offers profound insights into the type of government that, in his view, would best lead to human flourishing. Rutherford's principles, deeply rooted in Reformed theology, emphasize the supremacy of law over arbitrary rule, the accountability of rulers to the governed and to God, and the necessity of limited and constitutional government. These ideas have significantly influenced the development of modern political thought, particularly in the context of constitutionalism and the rule of law.
1. The Supremacy of Law Over the King
A central tenet of Rutherford’s Lex, Rex is the idea that the law is above the king. This principle asserts that rulers are not above the law but are subject to it. Rutherford argued against the doctrine of the divine right of kings, which held that monarchs were appointed by God and were thus accountable only to Him. Instead, Rutherford contended that even the king must obey the law, as the law is an expression of God's justice and order.
This principle of the supremacy of law is foundational for a government that promotes human flourishing. When rulers are bound by the law, they are less likely to abuse their power, leading to a more just and stable society. Rutherford’s emphasis on the rule of law is a precursor to modern constitutionalism, where governments are constrained by laws and constitutions designed to protect the rights and freedoms of individuals.
2. The Accountability of Rulers
Rutherford also emphasized the accountability of rulers, both to the people they govern and to God. In Lex, Rex, he argued that rulers derive their authority from the consent of the governed, a radical idea at the time. This means that political power is not inherent in the ruler but is entrusted to them by the people for the purpose of serving the common good. If rulers fail to uphold justice and protect the rights of their subjects, the people have the right to resist and even depose them.
This concept of accountability ensures that rulers cannot govern tyrannically without facing consequences. It places a moral and legal check on the exercise of power, promoting a government that serves the interests of the people rather than the personal ambitions of the ruler. Such accountability is essential for human flourishing, as it fosters a political environment where justice, fairness, and the protection of individual rights are prioritized.
3. The Principle of Limited Government
Rutherford was a strong advocate for limited government, arguing that the powers of rulers should be clearly defined and restricted by law. He believed that unchecked power inevitably leads to tyranny and oppression. In Lex, Rex, Rutherford proposed that the government should be divided into different branches or estates, each with specific roles and responsibilities. This division of power is intended to prevent any one person or group from gaining absolute control, thereby safeguarding the liberties of the people.
Limited government is crucial for human flourishing because it prevents the concentration of power in the hands of a few, reducing the risk of abuse and corruption. It allows for a system of checks and balances, where different branches of government can hold each other accountable. This not only protects individual freedoms but also encourages a more participatory and representative form of governance, where the voices of the people are heard and respected.
4. The Importance of Covenant and Contract
Rutherford's political thought is deeply influenced by the Reformed concept of covenant, which he applies to the relationship between rulers and the governed. He viewed the government as a covenantal institution, where both the ruler and the people are bound by mutual obligations. The ruler is obliged to govern justly and in accordance with the law, while the people are obliged to obey lawful authority. However, if the ruler breaks this covenant by acting unjustly or tyrannically, the people are released from their obligation to obey and may resist or replace the ruler.
This covenantal approach to government fosters human flourishing by emphasizing mutual responsibility and accountability. It ensures that political power is exercised within a framework of trust and obligation, rather than through coercion or fear. This creates a more stable and just society, where the rights and dignity of all individuals are respected.
5. The Role of Religion and Morality in Governance
Finally, Rutherford believed that true human flourishing is only possible when government is rooted in Christian principles and values. He argued that rulers should govern in a way that is consistent with God’s moral law, as revealed in Scripture. This includes promoting justice, protecting the vulnerable, and ensuring that the government does not become an instrument of oppression. Rutherford’s view is that a government detached from moral and religious foundations is prone to corruption and tyranny.
This principle underscores the importance of morality in public life. A government that promotes virtuous living and upholds moral standards contributes to the well-being of society as a whole. It encourages a culture of integrity, responsibility, and care for one another, all of which are essential for human flourishing.
Conclusion
Samuel Rutherford’s Lex, Rex presents a vision of government that is deeply concerned with the well-being of society and the protection of individual rights. By advocating for the supremacy of law, the accountability of rulers, limited government, covenantal relationships, and the integration of moral principles in governance, Rutherford offers a blueprint for a government that leads to human flourishing. His ideas have had a lasting impact on the development of constitutional democracy and continue to resonate in discussions about the proper role of government in society. Through these principles, Rutherford contributes to a Reformed understanding of political order that seeks to glorify God while promoting justice, peace, and prosperity for all.
-----
Lex Rex (eBook) by Samuel Rutherfored